Tuesday, February 25, 2014

Review: The Sentinels of Andersonville

The Sentinels of Andersonville
By Tracy Groot
Tyndale, 2014


We are rebels, are we not? Then let us rebel against what is not us.

Near the end of the Civil War, inhumane conditions at Andersonville Prison caused the deaths of 13,000 Union soldiers in only one year. In this gripping and affecting novel, three young Confederates and an entire town come face-to-face with the prison’s atrocities and will learn the cost of compassion, when withheld and when given.

Sentry Dance Pickett has watched, helpless, for months as conditions in the camp worsen by the day. He knows any mercy will be seen as treason. Southern belle Violet Stiles cannot believe the good folk of Americus would knowingly condone such barbarism, despite the losses they’ve suffered. When her goodwill campaign stirs up accusations of Union sympathies and endangers her family, however, she realizes she must tread carefully. Confederate corporal Emery Jones didn’t expect to find camaraderie with the Union prisoner he escorted to Andersonville. But the soldier’s wit and integrity strike a chord in Emery. How could this man be an enemy? Emery vows that their unlikely friendship will survive the war—little knowing what that promise will cost him.

As these three young Rebels cross paths, Emery leads Dance and Violet to a daring act that could hang them for treason. Wrestling with God’s harsh truth, they must decide, once and for all, Who is my neighbor?

My thoughts

It seems kind of trite to say that "this is my first Tracy Groot story, but it won't be my last" - yet that is certainly true in my case. Tracy says on her website that she has found her niche writing stories built around historical events, and while I haven't read her earlier books, I would have to agree with that statement. If you, like me, want Christian fiction that challenges, confronts, inspires, motivates, and entertains at the same time, then The Sentinels of Andersonville is for you.

I was drawn to this book because I enjoy character-driven drama, as well as southern fiction, and The Sentinels of Andersonville takes place in my own state of Georgia - but little did I know of the atrocities that took place there. Tracy begins her narrative with these cold, hard facts:

"During the last fourteen months of the Civil War, Andersonville Prison in Sumter County, Georgia, was a place of unimaginable suffering. In fourteen months, 45,000 men passed through the gates. Of those, 13,000 died, primarily from starvation and exposure."

Characterization centers around three Southerners - Sentry Dance Pickett, Corporal Emery Jones, Southern belle Violet Stiles - and Union prisoner Lew Gann, with whom Emery formed an "uncommon friendship." That friendship is at the heart of this story, and it reflects the kind of love to which Christ calls us. I loved this conversation between Lew and Emery early in the story:

Lew: "We had an escaped Negro following our camp. We had to saw a neck iron off him. Tricky work. As we did so, we observed his condition, and it was bad. Had a cut-off ear. Had a brand on his thigh, made by a hot iron. And his back . . . You are the South to me, and I know you don't have it in you to treat a man like that. So I want to know why you fight for those who do."

Emery: "The whole South ain't that way, and a man can be against slavery without being Union. He can just love his home, and love his people, and fight because you are down here and we're afraid of what you might do. . . . Decent folk, both sides; folk suitable for tar and feathers, both sides."

But the main character is the Andersonville military prison located outside the South Georgia town of Americus. Andersonville was a place where politics reigned supreme, and any kindness or sympathy toward the Yankee prisoners was perceived as treason. "If hell is a province or a state or a country, Andersonville is a town in it," according to Dance. Such was the depth of bitterness and hatred for the North that the town of Americus was able to forget these men were human and turn a blind eye.  Dance says: "They are not men, according to General Winder. They are a species called 'Yankee,' and woe to the one who thinks he sees in them a form like unto humanity."


"To feed these enemies is to forgive them," said Dr. Stiles.
"That, my girl, this town will not do."

But in this story, Tracy has taken what could potentially be an uncomfortable read, infused it with naturally-flowing wit and humor, added some wonderful plot twists that come out of left field, and made it highly entertaining - and that's a great gift. Spiritual themes of sacrifice, loyalty, and the desire to risk all in order to make a difference will speak to any reader.

Who, indeed, is my neighbor? The Sentinels of Andersonville asks this question in a pointed way and lets readers determine the answer for themselves. Thank you for a moving and compelling book, Tracy Groot! Highly recommended to all readers.

Tracy Groot

Tracy writes in the Afterword section . . .

"A day is coming, and may be here, when we will no longer look to the social activist to lead us. A day is coming, and may be here, when we will look for small things to do tirelessly within our own sphere, small things that could make life-changing differences for the people all around us. Not as much 'what would Jesus do?' . . . but rather, what will I do?"

Meet Tracy online at:

Thank you to Tyndale for providing a copy of this book in exchange for my honest review.


  1. Thanks for your review of this book. I am going to put this one on my book club schedule as a surprise selection. Not only is it set only 45 minutes south of us, but Groot is an excellent writer! My second book club read Flame of Resistance for our January meeting -- really great book. I highly recommend it.

    Thanks, Carole, for your insightful posts.

  2. Thanks for a great review Carole!
    I want to read this book now. I too enjoy "Christian fiction that challenges, confronts, inspires, motivates, and entertains at the same time". When I am reading whether Christian fiction or other, I want to be edified as well as entertained. I want to come out saying I "learned" something and because of it am a better person. I had never heard of this author before, so am excited to add Tracy to my "want to read - new authors". Always enjoy visiting your blog!

  3. Carole, very much enjoyed this blog post and your review.

  4. Thanks for your review, Carole. I saw and Ancestry.com show with Chris Donnelly, one of his ancestors had been a prisoner at Andersonville for a short time, but had escaped shortly after being imprisoned there. On the show they shared some of the horrible things that went on in there, even showing some pictures of the emaciated prisoners - just skin on bones. I am a Southerner by choice and hate the idea that any Southerner could have allowed such a thing to have happened, but there is evil everywhere in this world and it is the Spirit of God in the few that make this life better. I've read Tracy's books before and look forward to reading this one too. Kim